How to Check an Automated ARV Before You Make an Offer
By the ACC Solutions Team
Short answer: before you make an offer off an automated ARV, spend 15 minutes checking three things: that the comps really match the house (location, size, beds and baths, and condition after rehab), that each comp was a normal market sale and not a family transfer, sheriff sale or land bank sale, and that the subject property's own facts (square footage, year built) are right. If the automated number holds up, offer with confidence. If it doesn't, adjust before you commit.
Who wrote this: the ACC Solutions Team. ACC Software, part of ACC Solutions, makes the A.I. Deal Assistant, which gives ARV from recent comps, a rehab estimate and projected flip profit from an address or a Zillow or listing link. Product facts come from our A.I. Deal Assistant page and pricing page, read November 15, 2026. Our own disclaimer applies to any automated tool, including ours: results "are estimates to help you screen deals. They are not appraisals or inspections. Always confirm the numbers with your own due diligence."
Why the check matters right before an offer
ARV drives every other number in a flip. Using the 70% rule as an example, a $10,000 error in ARV moves your maximum offer by $7,000. Automated tools are fast at pulling recent sales, but they can't always tell a renovated house from a gutted one, or a market sale from a transfer between relatives. Those are the errors this check catches.
Check 1: Do the comps match the house?
- Same area. In Cleveland and its inner-ring suburbs, values can change a lot from one side of a major street to the other. Comps from the same neighborhood and school district count most.
- Similar size and layout. Look at square footage, beds and baths, and style. A 1,600 sq ft colonial and a 1,100 sq ft bungalow don't comp each other well.
- Renovated condition. ARV is after repair, so the comps should be houses that sold in the condition you plan to deliver. Look at listing photos if you can.
- Recent. The more recent the sale, the more it tells you about today's market.
Our guide on how to pull comps for a flip goes deeper on picking and adjusting comps.
Check 2: Was each comp a normal market sale?
Every recorded sale has a price, but not every price is a market price. In Cuyahoga County, the conveyance fee form buyers file (DTE 100) asks about conditions of sale such as a grantor who is a relative, a part-interest transfer, a land contract, a trade, a gift, or a grantor who is the mortgagee. The county's sales questionnaire goes further and asks about family sales, transfers between affiliated businesses, auction sales, forced or sheriff's sales, sales involving a government agency, partial interests, trades and sales by judicial order. The form says that information is used to determine whether a transfer is an arm's-length, market-based sale.
For your comps, the lesson is simple: when a sale price is far below its neighbors, check what kind of sale it was before you let it pull your ARV down. Look up the comp's address on Cuyahoga County MyPlace and read its transfer history. Watch especially for:
- Sheriff's sales. Sold as-is, often sight unseen, usually not a picture of renovated value.
- Land bank sales. County land bank properties often sell at very low prices with rehab requirements attached. Our post on analyzing a Cuyahoga Land Bank house as a flip explains how those deals work.
- Bank-owned sales and quick resales. A house that sold low and resold months later after a rehab gives you two data points: the as-is price and the after-repair price.
- Very low or nominal prices between people with the same last name, or between an owner and an LLC.
Check 3: Are the subject property's facts right?
An automated estimate starts from the property's recorded facts. The A.I. Deal Assistant shows a property snapshot with beds, baths and year built. Compare them against the county record and the listing. If the record shows three bedrooms and the listing shows four because an attic was finished without a permit, the comps you choose change. Look at the building information and permits on MyPlace while you're there.
Check 4: Does the rehab match the ARV?
ARV and rehab are linked. If your comps are fully renovated houses with new kitchens and baths, your rehab budget has to include new kitchens and baths. If you plan a lighter cosmetic job, use comps that sold in that condition. The A.I. Deal Assistant's rehab estimate comes from "square-footage logic plus national and local cost data," so it doesn't know whether the roof is 20 years old. Adjust for what you see or what an inspection tells you. Our post on estimating rehab cost per square foot covers the method.
A 15-minute routine before every offer
- Run the address in the A.I. Deal Assistant and note ARV, rehab and projected profit.
- Pick the three closest comps and confirm location, size, condition and date.
- Look up each comp's transfer on MyPlace and drop any that weren't market sales.
- Check the subject's beds, baths, square footage and year built against the record.
- If your checked ARV is lower, re-run your offer with the lower number. If it's higher, don't raise your offer on hope; keep the cushion.
When not to rely on an analyzer at all, for example unusual properties with no real comps, is covered in when not to use a deal analyzer.
Try it on your next offer
The Free plan includes 10 searches with 72 hours of access, enough to run and check a few deals. Investor Pro - Solo is $47 per month for 3,000 searches per month, with automatic updates and batch search support. Enterprise (team licensing, custom reports, dedicated support) is "Let's talk." The subscription may be tax-deductible as a business expense; ask your CPA.
See plans and pricing · See how the A.I. Deal Assistant works
Buying in Cleveland? The "Need Help With This Flip?" button reaches the ACC team, which coordinates rehabs in Cuyahoga County, and ACC is crypto friendly for buyers paying in Bitcoin or Ethereum.
ACC Solutions Team
Phone: (216) 238-5999 · Email: support@accmgmtsolutions.com · Contact form
6545 Market Ave N, Canton, OH 44721
We work asynchronously, so you can reach us by email or the contact form from any time zone; you don't need to catch us during Ohio business hours.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I check an automated ARV?
Confirm the comps match the house in location, size and renovated condition, check that each comp was a normal market sale, and verify the subject property's own beds, baths, square footage and year built against the county record.
Why would a comp sale not count toward ARV?
Sales between relatives, sheriff's sales, land bank sales, part-interest transfers, trades and gifts often don't reflect market value. Cuyahoga County's own sales questionnaire uses these conditions to judge whether a sale was arm's-length.
How much does an ARV error change my offer?
Using the 70% rule as an example, every $10,000 of ARV error moves the maximum offer by $7,000, before any change in the rehab estimate.
Is the A.I. Deal Assistant ARV an appraisal?
No. Results are estimates to help you screen deals. They are not appraisals or inspections. Always confirm the numbers with your own due diligence.
How many free searches does the A.I. Deal Assistant include?
The Free plan includes 10 searches with access for 72 hours. Investor Pro - Solo is $47 per month for 3,000 searches per month.